Your Comprehensive Guide to The Lost Kitchen Dessert Recipes

Step into the world of The Lost Kitchen, a culinary delight tucked away in Freedom, Maine. Owned and operated by Erin French, this hidden gem embodies the spirit of home cooking, emphasizing fresh, local ingredients.

The Lost Kitchen is renowned for its farm-to-table philosophy, a principle that underlines every dish that emerges from the kitchen. Housed in a refurbished mill, it welcomes patrons from far and wide, each eager to taste French’s exceptional cooking. 

While the menu is noteworthy, The Lost Kitchen’s desserts are unique in diners’ hearts. Ranging from rustic classics to innovative creations, each dessert is a tribute to simplicity, seasonality, and taste. This natural, soul-warming approach sets The Lost Kitchen’s desserts apart.

Discovering The Lost Kitchen Desserts: An Expert’s Take

Having been fortunate enough to dine at The Lost Kitchen and attend a cooking demonstration by Erin French, I offer an insider’s perspective into these delectable desserts.

Personal Experience and Expertise in The Lost Kitchen Desserts

The first time I tried The Lost Kitchen’s signature Apple Cider Doughnut Sundae, it was a revelation. Each component was perfectly balanced, from the freshly-baked doughnuts to the tart apple cider reduction and creamy vanilla ice cream. This experience sparked a love affair with these desserts, leading me to explore and recreate these recipes at home.

Authenticity and Originality of The Lost Kitchen Dessert Recipes

What truly distinguishes The Lost Kitchen desserts is their authenticity. Each recipe reflects the season’s bounty, as French creatively transforms local produce into something spectacular. Whether it’s the blueberry custard tart in summer or the maple syrup pudding in winter, these desserts are an ode to Maine’s rich produce and the creativity of the French’s culinary mind.

Learn more About Your Ultimate Guide to a Delightful Gluten-Free Au Jus Recipe!

Deep-Dive into The Lost Kitchen Dessert Recipes

Ready to recreate these delicious desserts at home? Here’s a deep dive into three of my favorite recipes.

Recipe 1: Key Ingredients and Detailed Steps

Apple Cider Doughnut Sundae:


  • For doughnuts: all-purpose flour, baking powder, salt, nutmeg, egg, sugar, apple cider, melted butter, and vanilla extract.
  • For sundae: vanilla ice cream, caramel sauce, whipped cream, and toasted walnuts.


  1. Begin by making the doughnuts. Mix the dry ingredients in one bowl and the wet ones in another. Combine the two, being careful not to overmix.
  2. Pipe the batter into a doughnut mold and bake at 350°F for 10-12 minutes.
  3. Once cooled, assemble your sundae. Start with a doughnut, then layer with ice cream, caramel sauce, another doughnut, more ice cream, and finally, top with whipped cream and toasted walnuts.

Recipe 2: Key Ingredients and Detailed Steps

Blueberry Custard Tart:


  • For the crust: all-purpose flour, sugar, salt, unsalted butter, and ice water.
  • For filling: fresh blueberries, sugar, eggs, cream, and vanilla extract.


  1. Begin by preparing the crust. Combine the dry ingredients, then cut in the butter until you get a crumbly texture. Add in the water until the dough comes together. Roll out, fit into a tart tin, and chill.
  2. Whisk together the sugar, eggs, cream, and vanilla for the filling. Arrange the blueberries on the chilled crust, then pour over the custard mixture.
  3. Bake at 375°F until the crust is golden and the custard is set for 30-35 minutes.

Recipe 3: Key Ingredients and Detailed Steps

Maple Syrup Pudding:


  • For pudding: milk, cornstarch, salt, egg yolks, maple syrup, and unsalted butter.
  • For topping: whipped cream and toasted pecans.


  1. Mix the cornstarch and salt in milk to make a smooth slurry.
  2. Heat the rest of the milk with the syrup until it’s warm, then slowly whisk in the slurry. Cook until it thickens.
  3. Off heat, stir in the beaten egg yolks and butter until smooth. Pour into serving dishes and chill until set.
  4. Serve topped with whipped cream and toasted pecans.

Tips and Tricks for Mastering These Desserts

While each recipe comes with instructions, there are a few universal tips to remember. Always use the freshest ingredients, and remember, precision is key in the world of desserts – so invest in a good set of measuring tools. And finally, as French says, “Don’t be scared to make a mess. It’s just food.” Embrace the process, and you’re sure to whip up something delicious!

Importance of Quality Ingredients in The Lost Kitchen Recipes

At the heart of The Lost Kitchen’s charm is the reliance on fresh, locally sourced ingredients. Just as Erin French takes pride in the quality of her produce, home cooks, too, must understand the importance of ingredient selection in replicating these desserts.

Ingredient Sourcing and Selection: What Makes a Difference?

Every dessert recipe begins at the market – with a selection of high-quality, fresh ingredients. Seek local farmers’ markets or specialized grocers for fresh produce and dairy. Opt for high-quality variants for items like pure maple syrup or vanilla extract – they can make a difference in the final taste.

Impact of High-Quality Ingredients on the Final Outcome 

The quality of your ingredients can profoundly affect the final dessert. Fresh, high-quality ingredients provide better taste and texture, enhancing the overall sensory experience of your dessert. Furthermore, they also contribute to better nutritional value.

Mobile-Friendly: Adapting Recipes for Home Cooks

While The Lost Kitchen’s recipes are inherently simple, some modifications can make them more accessible to home cooks.

Simplifying The Lost Kitchen Dessert Recipes for Home Cooking

Adapting these recipes for home cooking is all about focusing on technique and balance. For instance, when making the Apple Cider Doughnut Sundae, you could use store-bought doughnuts to save time instead of making the doughnuts from scratch. However, remember to maintain quality.

Essential Tools for The Lost Kitchen Recipes at Home

While professional kitchen tools can be beneficial, all you need are the basics: a good set of measuring instruments for accuracy, a reliable oven for baking, and quality pans and molds for shaping your desserts. A hand or stand mixer can also be helpful, though optional.

Enhancing Your Dessert Experience: Expert Advice

Mastering The Lost Kitchen dessert recipes aren’t just about recreating them to the tee; it’s also about adding your touch to enhance the experience.

Expert Tips for The Best Dessert Presentation

Presentation is a huge part of the dessert experience. Be patient with your presentation for a rustic, homey look like The Lost Kitchen. Serve your desserts in beautiful ceramic dishes, garnish with fresh herbs, and don’t be afraid to let your dessert look homemade – it’s part of the charm!

Pairing The Lost Kitchen Desserts with Drinks

The right drink can complement your dessert and make it even more enjoyable. For the Apple Cider Doughnut Sundae, hot apple cider would be a great match. The Blueberry Custard Tart would pair beautifully with sweet white wine. At the same time, the Maple Syrup Pudding could be accompanied by a rich coffee or even a glass of dessert wine. Remember, the best pairing is one that you enjoy!

Celebrating The Lost Kitchen: The Joy of Cooking and Sharing

Cooking and sharing food, particularly desserts can be a deeply fulfilling experience. The Lost Kitchen recipes embody this sentiment, fostering community and togetherness.

Personal Stories of Making and Sharing The Lost Kitchen Desserts

One winter evening, I decided to make The Lost Kitchen’s Apple Cider Doughnut Sundae. The aroma of simmering apple cider and baking doughnuts wafted through my home, drawing my family to the kitchen. The joy on their faces as they tasted the dessert, was a priceless moment, reinforcing the magical bond between food, love, and togetherness.

How These Recipes Can Bring People Together

The Lost Kitchen Desserts are not just about creating sweet treats; they’re about fostering connections. Making these recipes for family gatherings or dinner parties, or even a quiet evening at home, can be a way of showing care and love. The shared experience of enjoying these delightful desserts can deepen relationships and create lasting memories.

Read Related: Your Ultimate Guide to Low-Sodium Dessert Recipes | Deliciously Heart-Healthy

Final Thought

As we end our journey through The Lost Kitchen dessert recipes, it’s essential to remember that cooking is a creative and personal process open to interpretation and improvisation.

Mastering these dessert recipes is more than just about following the instructions in the letter. It’s about understanding the philosophy behind Erin French’s approach to food – simplicity, quality, and a deep respect for ingredients.

As we look to the future, we can expect The Lost Kitchen to continue inspiring home cooks worldwide, emphasizing simple, high-quality desserts. Ultimately, the heart of The Lost Kitchen’s dessert philosophy – cooking with love and care – is timeless. And that is something all of us can strive for in our kitchens, now and always.

Mahadi Hasan

Mahadi Hasan is a culinary whiz specializing in recipe tips, healthy desserts, gluten-free delights, and keto-friendly meals. Your go-to expert for flavorful, nutritious cooking.

4 thoughts on “Your Comprehensive Guide to The Lost Kitchen Dessert Recipes”

Leave a Comment